In The News Trip Reports Features Land Use Doh! Photo Album Cover Shots
Project Vehicles Product Reviews Quick Looks Wrenching Featured Vehicles YJ FAQ Calculators
BC 4x4 Suppliers 4x4 Suppliers For Sale Ads Wanted Ads
Coming Events Links Message Board Mailing List


Project YJ - Detroit Locker vs. Lockright
Introduction
Installation
Test Drive
Conclusion

 
 

 
 
Project YJ Articles
Introduction
Detailed History
Rubicon Express
Spring-Over
Bumper/Tire Rack
Rhino Liner
Scout Axle Swap
Detroit Lockers
vs. Lockrights
TeraLow Dana 300 4:1 Kit
Go 2 Twister Dana 300 Re-Indexer
Bestop Supertop
Transmission Overhaul
TJ Flares Install
Rocker Armour
Bestop TrailMax Aqua Sport Seats
Kilby Gas Tank Skid Plate
Teraflex Revolvers
Kilby High Volume Automatic Transmission Pan
Hi-Steer Conversion

 
 

Test Drive

The toughest test a locker must withstand isn't on some rock crawling trail. It's the day-to-day use dished out by 4x4s that are used as commuter vehicles during the week and offroad toys on the weekend. All those miles spent on high traction surfaces exact a toll on the locker's toothed clutches. They can also make for a very unpleasant driving experience.

I've always been told that automatic lockers are bad for daily driver 4x4s because they have so much backlash and suffer from strong throttle-steering around corners. That is, when you're going around a corner, the vehicle tends to try to go straight when you get on the throttle, and tends to turn harder when you get off the throttle. Hence the term, throttle-steer. And it's true, you do get that with automatic lockers. By the same token, lift kits degrade the handling of your 4x4 and bigger tires do the same. The question is, how much are you willing to accept in exchange for the improved off-road abilities?

With my Lockrights, the throttle-steer was noticeable but manageable. It was always predictable so I was prepared and could easily deal with it. The fact that Project YJ has an automatic transmission also reduced the effect which is stronger with manual transmissions. With the Detroit Lockers, however, I was absolutely amazed at how much the throttle-steer was minimized. The transition between locked and unlocked was much smoother. The click-click-click that is typical of lunch box lockers was also gone, although I must admit that, in a weird way, I kind of miss that sound.

These surprise benefits in my Jeep's pavement manners were just the icing on the cake because as I stated in the introduction, the reason I went with Detroits is for their legendary reliability. To have that, and then discover that it also has better highway manners has put me over the top.

The following weekend I took the YJ for a test drive on some of our more difficult local trails and the Jeep performed flawlessly with the new Detroits. One thing that I was concerned about was the effect the front Detroit would have on my steering. I had heard from a few people that a Lockright in the front axle allowed for easier steering because it "unlocked" more easily. I found this not to be true. There was no difference in steering effort required between the Lockrights and the new Detroits.


 
 
 

Previous | Menu |  Next
BC4x4 Main Page
Click to Send Email
to BC4x4
(20-sec delay)
SEARCH
ARTICLES
In The News
Trip Reports
Features
Land Use
Doh!
Photo Album
Cover Shots
TECH
Project Vehicles
Product Reviews
Quick Looks
Wrenching
Featured Vehicles
YJ FAQ
Calculators
MARKETPLACE
BC4x4 Suppliers
4x4 Suppliers
Message Board
FOR SALE Ads
WANTED Ads
RESOURCES
Coming Events
Links
Message Board
BC4x4 Mailing Lists

Except where otherwise noted, all contents on this site are Copyright 1999 - 2009 © 599244 BC Ltd. All rights reserved. No content on this site may be reproduced without express permission from 599244 BC Ltd.
Disclaimer: Activities and vehicle modifications appearing or described on this website and its pages may be potentially dangerous. We do not endorse any such activity for others or recommend it to any particular person - we simply describe our experiences and opinions. If you choose to engage in these activities, it is by your own free will and at your own volition. Use common sense and remember that none of this material is presented as being recommended by a professional mechanic or driving instructor. This information is presented for your amusement only. Do not take unwise risks, consult a certified professional if you are not sure of something. - 599244 BC Ltd. (bc4x4.com) and the authors of these articles assume no liability for how any particular individual chooses to use the information presented here.