I wouldn't put anything larger than what you have on there until you get more lift. 32's would be fine for the road but would rub like crazy off road. I have a 3" body and 32x11.5 and mine rub off-road even with a sway bar attached!! I too like the look of plenty of room between the fender and tire.
------------------
Play hard + Rest easy
Drive a Jeep
'92 YJ

------------------
Play hard + Rest easy
Drive a Jeep
'92 YJ